Visiting the A-Bomb Memorials in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

Share!
nagasaki memorial_

The somber memorial at Nagasaki. The two columns are illuminated by the light of the sky. They point at the epicenter of the blast, 250 meters away. The rack visible in the center holds the books with the names of the Nagasaki dead, nearly 160,000 of them.

My father was a World War II veteran. He saw some terrible things that he would never talk about. He was at Omaha Beach, Bastogne, the Huertgen Forest and participated in the disastrous operation Market Garden in Holland. Only under prodding would he occasionally reveal sketchy details of what he had seen.

But I remember clearly one thing he once said: “I felt so sorry for the civilians. We saw them walking away from towns we were fighting in carrying whatever they could. But, sometimes they just couldn’t get out of the way. Every time I’d see a dead mother or child, it just broke my heart.”

Dad fought in Europe. But I also remember a discussion we had when I was a teenager fascinated with World War II history. It was about using the atomic bombs on Japan. He said we had to do it or many more Americans would have been killed in an invasion.

One thing was certain: the Japanese were ferocious fighters–as we had found out first hand all through the Pacific island campaign. They also had a justified reputation for mistreating their conquered foes and prisoners of war. The thought of having to invade Japan in order to put and end to World War II was distasteful to everyone.

But after seeing the record of destruction in Hiroshima and Nagasaki during the past week, I can’t help but ask if we couldn’t have figured something else out to get Japan to surrender.

Here are a few things I learned at the A-bomb memorials.

Tanaka Kio Nagasaki victim

This photo of Tanaka Kio, a mother of three, nursing her burned four-month-old son the day after the blast in Nagasaki. Her son died a few days later, as did her elder son, who was also horribly burned. They were 1.8 kilometers from the epicenter of the blast. Tanako lived to be 91 years old. She died in 2006 in Nagasaki. This photo is displayed, along with many other disturbing ones taken soon after the bombing, in the Nagasaki Memorial Museum.

The US and its allies never considered using the A-bombs on Germany. For some reason, Japan was to be the only target. I’ll leave it to you to come up with your own theories as to why that was the case.

We gave no warning about the bombs. We dropped them both in areas that contained some military targets, but also schools, shops, and homes, and, in the case of Nagasaki, farmers’ fields far from the center of the city.

Before we dropped the A-bombs, we stopped our conventional air attacks on the possible target cities. This was to preserve the cities so that we could accurately assess the destruction the A-bombs did.

Our “conventional” bombing attacks in the four months before the A-bomb attacks included incendiary bombing of entire cities. We killed over 100,000 in one night in Tokyo with such an attack–more than were killed immediately by either of the A-bombs.

One of the reasons we wanted to use the A-bombs at all was to justify their cost to the American people. It was, of course, the most expensive weapons program ever undertaken.

Another reason was that we foresaw our pending conflict with our “ally” the Soviet Union. We wanted to flex our muscles with them after they, after all, had done more to defeat Hitler than we had, and were currently occupying all of Eastern Europe. They were also poised to finally enter the war against Japan after we had done all the heavy lifting in the Pacific. We wanted to put a stop to them getting an advantage over an already defeated Japan.

So, we weigh these revelations together with the horrible images of the Japanese mothers and children on the ground at Hiroshima and Nagasaki. As my Dad said, “they just couldn’t get out of the way.” And that breaks the heart of anyone who goes to those memorials today.

hiroshima a-bomb dome

The bombed out shell of what had been a community gathering place in Hiroshima. It was about 160 meters from the epicenter of the blast there.

,

3 Responses to Visiting the A-Bomb Memorials in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

  1. Patti October 3, 2013 at 11:51 am #

    What an interesting and moving post. Haunting images.
    Patti recently posted…Where’s the Beef?My Profile

    • Tom Bartel October 3, 2013 at 5:51 pm #

      Thanks, Patti. What can I say other than I think everyone should see these places. Maybe we’d be a little less likely to start bombing Iraq, and Afghanistan, and Syria, and wherever else the politicians think is “good policy” or “teaching someone a lesson.”
      Tom Bartel recently posted…Women Taking Each Other’s Photo, Nara, JapanMy Profile

  2. Kit Naylor October 5, 2013 at 12:39 pm #

    Thanks for this, Tom. Insightful analysis. I’ve often wondered why we didn’t warn the Japanese about the bomb, demonstrated it on less populated areas… but you’re right, after spending all that money the scientists and General Groves wanted to see how well it worked.

    I recommend to you the 1959 film “Hiroshima, mon amour,” directed by Alain Renais. From IMDB: “A French actress filming an anti-war film in Hiroshima has an affair with a married Japanese architect as they share their differing perspectives on war.” And of course the 1977 film directed by Richard Attenborough, “A Bridge Too Far.” Operation Market Garden was the most incredible f-up. The higher-ups ignored on the ground intelligence about increase in enemy forces (German tanks spotted outside Arnhem). Liv Ullmann played one of the civilians…

    I wish I’d been able to meet your father. He must have been a very brave man.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

Google